Trophies:
Bronze trophies
Dig that long ball – In any mode (excluding HRD) hit a Home Run with a pitcher.
Strong Arm – Throw the ball into the stands when attempting to throw out a runner at 1st.
Fill’er Up – After falling behind in the count 0-2 work back to a full count. Must be completed vs. the CPU with both pitching and batting set to All-Star or higher difficulty.
Sell Your Body – Make a diving catch in foul territory for an out.
Patience… – Draw a 4 pitch walk in any mode. Must be completed vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Pesky… – In any single at bat, see 10 or more pitches. Must be completed vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Lean On Me – Pick off the CPU runner on 1st.
The Bacon – In RttS, earn more than 20,000,000 over the course of your career.
Cooperation – Win a co-op game.
Advanced Cooperation – With different users controlling the pitcher and fielders, complete a strike ’em out throw ’em out double play.
Experienced – Accumulate 100 XP across any online game modes.
Have a CoW Man! – Compete in the Challenge of the Week in back to back weeks.
Momma’s Boy – In any season mode, hit a Home Run on Mother’s Day with a pink bat.
Daddy Long Legs – In any season mode, hit a triple on Father’s Day.
Poor Billy… – Win a game on an error.
Stone Hands – Make 5 or more errors in a single game.
The Billy Goat – In Season or Franchise mode, win the World Series as the Cubs. Good luck, you’re going to need it! Must be full 9 inning games, simulating of World Series games will invalidate the trophy.
Splash Down II – Hit a Home Run into the hot tub in Chase field.
Swim With The Fishes – Hit a Home Run into the Ray’s aquarium.
Stay on Target – At Target Field, land your foul ball or tailing Home Run on the Target sign down the right field line.
Ice Cold – Hit a Home Run to dead center in Coors Field.
Salute the Troops – Win a game using the Padres while wearing Camo Jerseys.
Day at the Beach – Hit a Home Run into the sand at Petco Park.
Tough Loss – As the away team, take a shutout into the bottom of the 9th and lose the game. Must be completed vs. the CPU.
Silver trophies
Running Down a Dream – In a single game, steal 3rd twice. Must be completed vs. the CPU.
Batting Performance Evaluated – As a Batter in RttS, have 3 or more ‘Good’ or better At Bats in a single game at the MLB Level.
Pitching Performance Evaluated – As a Pitcher in RttS, in a single game, face 6 or more consecutive batters achieving a ‘Good’ or better rating at the MLB Level.
Seasoned – Achieve an All-Star rank across all online game modes.
Challenger – Place in the top 33% in any single week of Challenge of the Week.
Gold trophies
Insider – In any mode get an inside the park Home Run. Must be completed vs. the CPU.
Psychic – With Guess Pitch on, in any mode, correctly guess 10 pitches in a row (Location OR Pitch) vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Beat LA – Beat the Dodgers. Must be completed vs. the CPU with both pitching and batting set to Legend. RttS excluded.
Yankees ‘Inhale Deeply Through The Mouth’! – Beat the Yankees. Must be completed vs. the CPU with both pitching and batting set to Legend. RttS excluded.
Peak Training – In RTTS, reach level 5 in all training modes as a pitcher or a batter.
Today… I am the greatest – In any mode, with any single player, accumulate 130 or more stolen bases in a single Season.
Platinum trophy
100% Clear – Earn all Bronze, Silver, and Gold trophies.